Rain Jackets
This was originally written as a post on the A Run for the Ages Australia Facebook group immediately following the run on the weekend of June 3-5, 2023
Monday was a great opportunity to properly test out some rain gear (it rained, a lot!). I took three newish jackets with me for the weekend, all of which claim to be “waterproof and breathable”. Thanks to the four storm-fronts experienced during Monday, I was able to compare them side by side in some pretty damp conditions:
• The North Face Men’s Anotora Jacket ( 449 )
• Salomon Men’s Bonatti Trail WP Jacket ($198 )
The Salomon Bonatti is your typical “mandatory” race rain jacket choice - seam sealed, lightweight, packs down to nothing. Super comfortable, feels very light on the body. Has “Pertex Shield” branding on it, Elastic at the waist and wrist, with a hood perfectly shaped to go over your cap, and an ‘expandable back’ section that lets you wear it over a running pack. I’d say this is a great jacket to carry when there’s only a low to moderate chance of rain, and when you expect you’ll be moving quickly all the time (and thus stay warm). However, it’s not ideal for the multi-day adventures or heavy coniditions as it didn’t really feel like it would hold the rain out forever. Being a super-light jacket, it doesn’t do too much to stop the wind.
The TNF Men’s Anotora Jacket was magnificent in Monday’s conditions. Waterproof, breathable, seam-sealed with a DryVent (TNF branding) shell, it provide substantial protection from the weather conditions. The hood was large enough to go over my cap, and I was able to close the head opening so that only my eyes, nose and mouth were uncovered. The wrists are elasticated, and there’s a drawstring around the waist. Front zipper has a strip covering it. It’s not the smallest of jackets to pack away, but it sure as heck kept me dry and warm, and was super-comfortable to wear — you can push the sleeves up and pull ‘em down to control body temp between storms, and it also ties neatly around your waist if you can’t be bothered putting it away in a pack. When I was getting changed at the end of the event, I was completely dry under this jacket.
Macpac Men’s Lightweight Prophet. I had really high expectations for this jacket, it cost a small fortune, was lightweight, with claims of 20,000 hoo-hars of water proofing and breathability. And, tbh, it did a good job of keeping the rain out and keeping me cool. However, the hood felt like I was wearing an elephant on my head, and no matter what I did, I couldn’t get it to fit comfortably while running through the heavy wind and rain. The lightweight nature of the jacket meant it didn’t really keep me warm like the TNF Antora. It used a velcro strip at the wrists, and had a drawstring at the waist, but neither were all that comfie to adjust. I’d say this is an excellent hiking jacket, and it’ll replace my 25 year old Mountain Designs Goretex jacket for future multi-day hikes, but I won’t be taking it running again.